A Game of Thrones by George R.R. Martin

Way back in June I did my review on the Song of Ice and Fire series by George R.R. Martin.  It wasn’t nice, or delicate.  And though my feelings on the overall series have not changed.  It is still long, drawn out, full of unnecessary elements, and will inevitably lead to a disappointing ending.  I feel like I do owe book one, A Game of Thrones, a much better review as a stand alone.  The ground-breaking novel deserves that much respect, and cannot be blamed for having four books after it that could have been one and a half, maybe two.  Or that Mr. Martin seems to have forgotten what he was doing entirely.  I stand by my assessment that 1.77 million words should get much more done, or… something done.  Before I get going on the mess that is the Song of Ice and Fire series, I will focus on the book that started it all, and should be credited as one of the landmark fantasy novels of our time.

A Game of Thrones was published over twenty years ago, on August 1, 1996.  Instantly gaining reception as one of the best fantasy novels in years.  Earning awards across the fantasy board including, a Locus Award, and a Hugo for the novella collecting the Blood of the Dragon storyline.  Many of todays biggest names in fantasy give the nod to George R.R. Martin for opening the doors and minds of what fantasy could be.  Today, A Game of Thrones is one of the best selling books of all time, and has spawned a franchise that stretches TV, games, comic books, and plenty of merchandise.

The plot is massive.  Considering the mass popularity of the books and TV series, it would be redundant of me to break it down.  Essentially, A Game of Thrones introduces us to Westeros, a fictional, medieval land of delicate politics.  With the fall of the countries long running, yet unstable, monarchy, the throne for Lord of the Seven Kingdoms is held in a delicate balance.  After established leader Robert Baratheon is poisoned, politics and deception play a major role in who is the next rightful leader.  Meanwhile, plenty of other side plots are unravelling.  Like the fate of the last survivors of the former monarchy, and their efforts to regain power.  And, the degenerating forces of a giant wall dedicated to keeping the undead in the frozen north.

There are many positives and negatives to this book, mostly positives each with a negative flaw.  The characters, and multiple POV’s were well planned out, creating a rich world of individuals.  Unfortunately, many of them are one dimensional and the author likes to put definitive lines between the good and the evil, with only rare glimpses of more natural personalities.  The drawn out descriptions of… everything, from food, clothing, weapons, the colour of the drapes, the condition of the walls, etc., are surprisingly easy to read, and at times enjoyable.  Although, in the long run, four books later, it all feels excessive.  What makes this book so strong is the intellectual chess game you bare witness to.  The pieces move flowingly, and naturally, with abrupt changes and major twists, keeping you intrigued from page one.  The flaw to this however, is it doesn’t all fit together.  Starting with zombies, ending with dragons and a whole slew of moving pieces in the middle, that fail to connect with each other, and never leading to an end.  Like, never.

Somehow, the powerful writing of this story makes you ignore all of the drawl, and tropes.  The historical political theories are captivating, propelling readers through the story for answers.  That is what George R.R. Martin gave us.  We no longer need fantastic imagery and magic to drive fantasy novels.  Since the release in 1996, the genre has exploded with new and exciting worlds and politics, focusing on story, instead of the fantastic.  For those of you eagerly awaiting the next installment from Mr. Martin, I would remember that this strong book took him five years to write.  That was with half the characters involved now, and only four settings.  He has built this series as big as his wall, and he has a lot of climbing to do to get out of it.  As for Game of Thrones, I will stick to my initial rating of 3/5.  This novel is an enjoyable read, and a landmark in the genre.  But, for me, the talented writing does not mask the major flaws of the overall book.  So, give it a read, but do yourself the favour of stopping there, or at most book three, there’s nothing substantial after that.

Thanks booknerds, I sure hope winter is ending soon…


17 Comments Add yours

  1. They may not be the most well written books of all time but I have to say that I love them all! Can’t comment on the show because I have not seen it.
    x The Captain

    Liked by 3 people

  2. AWW lord I can’t even express how badly I wish I would have read this before watching the shows!

    Liked by 2 people

    1. Green Onion says:

      Yeah, I hear you, kinda spoils the fun in reading

      Liked by 1 person

  3. Marta says:

    I really like the TV show, and I already saw the books at my local library so I’d like to pick them up one day, but I don’t think I’ll be doing it anytime soon, especially because everyone keeps saying they are quite boring … and, honestly, they’re HUGE haha But I’m glad the first one is better 🙂

    Liked by 1 person

    1. Green Onion says:

      The first book is worth the length, its well done and surprisingly easy to read.

      Liked by 2 people

      1. Marta says:

        Then I’ll check it out, maybe during summer break. Thanks!!

        Liked by 1 person

  4. I found the TV series interesting, and characters like tyrion, varys, little finger have a lot of depth. Characters like Hound and Theon do blur the line between good and bad and show the shades that lie in between.
    This was probably the first mainstream book that called so many of what the readers considered protagonists, starting with Ned Stark, then Robb Stark and so forth. If you glanced at the last episode of season 6, everything seems to be heading towards a collision. The houses are choosing sides, and I think the dragons will be essential in defeating the White Walkers.

    Liked by 2 people

    1. Green Onion says:

      I absolutely agree that further in the story he blends in many more “grey” characters, as far as the first book though, its much more ‘hate this character – like this one”. I have halted watching the show, as it has parts that have preceeded the books, so I dont want to waste that. My biggest concern is the show is writing the end first, and they need to so thats fair. It’s a great show

      Liked by 1 person

  5. Zezee says:

    Hmm. My initial reaction was to disagree with you on the characters being one-demensional, but when I think about it, I see your point. It’s pretty clear who the good and bad people are and several aren’t very complex though I do find them very interesting.
    I also think the ending of the series won’t be great. There is so much going on and, as you said, GRRM includes loads of details so I doubt 7 (or however much is planned) books won’t work.

    Liked by 1 person

  6. Christy Luis says:

    Great, thoughtful review! Thank you! I tried to read the first book (and I even got most of the way through it), but it’s just sooo long and detailed, and I had a hard time liking the characters. I ended up watching the tv season 1 instead just to finish off book 1. Good ending, but yeah…the problem may just be that I’m not a “grimdark” fan. I’ll need to read in the genre to decide for sure, I think. Anyway, I’m glad you enjoyed the first installment at least and I hope the series finale will be spectacular 🙂


  7. I have been reading books for quite a long time already and this particular one I haven’t had yet. I know it’s already a TV sensation yet stories are really different in books. Now, with all the rave and talks about GOT I want in. I’m going to buy one and be the judge myself.


  8. gogoanime says:

    Nice Share, Keep working hard!! 🙂


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s